.comment-link {margin-left:.6em;}

Gadget Blog Corrections Blog

An actually-researched look at gadget blog bullshit.

Saturday, September 16, 2006

D-ILA1080MF1: Lots of wrongness

Donald Melanson of Engadget takes a look at the Meridian Faroudja D-ILA1080MF1:
Our pals over at HD Beat continue to rock CEDIA, taking time to check out Meridian Faroudja's latest high-end projector offering -- the D-ILA1080PMF1 -- retailing for a hefty $20,995.. If you stare at that model name for a bit, you should realize that this one sports full 1080p with D-ILA technology backing it up.
Sadly there's not actually a "P" in the model number, but nice try. That's the first flag something wrong. We continue:
If there's one area where it comes up a bit short, however, it's inputs, with just RGB, s-video and DVI coming standard.
It's worse than that, it does 1080p DVI and that's it. But wait, there's an add-on video processor:
it adds multiple progressive analog video outputs/inputs including RGBHV, component, RGBS and RGsB
But those are all roughly the same thing - variants of analog component - so they're different formats, not different inputs. Lo and behold, the product brochure shows only one set of inputs, and in fact the processor is needed just to get the inputs that Engadget alleges are on the projector. As is common with Engadget, all of these errors are blindly copied from the source article. It's understandable HD Beat wouldn't have to time to check facts when they're blogging from the road (or at least pretending to be), but Engadget have all the time in the world and a complete set of easily-Googlable documents on Meridian's website, so apparently they just can't be bothered.


Post a Comment

Links to this post:

Create a Link

<< Home